A South African woman is appealing for the right to join her two boyfriends in the UK.
Simone Carmen Johnson has a polyamorous relationship with Tao Settembrini (previously Rochelle Settembrini) and Larissa Settembrini.
Johnson applied for an Unmarried Partner Visa on February 5, and her application was denied on June 26, citing eligible relationship restrictions under UK immigration law.
The refusal raised issues of discrimination and human rights. While polygamy is unconventional by traditional UK standards, it is legally recognized in South Africa and may violate Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to family life. This highlights a conflict between UK immigration policy and evolving global norms on family structures and LGBTQ+ rights.
Johnson claimed in her application to have her UK visa reconsidered that, while the refusal letter stated that the relationship did not meet the eligibility relationship requirement, it did not adequately consider the legality and validity of polygamous marriages and relationships recognised in South Africa.
“The refusal implies a lack of evidence for a genuine and subsisting relationship. This assessment neglects to consider the unique dynamics of polygamous relationships,” the application read.
UK Immigration and British Nationality Senior Manager at Move Up UK Visa Solutions, Gwen Vermeulen, told IOL that their refusal not only tears apart a loving family, but also raises troubling questions about the UK’s commitment to human rights and equality.
“We are urging the UK Home Office to reconsider this decision and recognise the validity of diverse family structures,” Vermeulen said.
She added that the case has drawn support from human rights organisations and LGBTQ+ advocates, who argue that the decision reflects outdated views on family and relationships.
According to Vermeulen, a formal request for reconsideration has been filed, citing legal precedents that support the recognition of foreign marriages and relationships.
“If unsuccessful, an appeal will be lodged with the relevant tribunal,” she added.
